Its Commendable, I appreciate the effort taken by you Nilesh and your AMC. It is high time when Fund manager from India show their Iron and take the credit they deserve.

Wonderful explanation. Very bold reply.

superb my personal request to all ifa friends pl.read ate lest 3 time before visit investor

Many Thanks for your feed back. Appreciate your support. Markets are volatile, they go up and down. The volatility of Market becomes Risk to the Investor only when we sell in fear or buy in greed. I seek support from all of you to ensure that the market volatility does not result into the risk to our investors. They have earned the money hard way. Please spread the message to all that every correction is a great opportunity to buy into the market.

Well said Mr Nilesh, though we need not reply to the comments of every tom, dick, (jim) and harry. We Indians have not tasted good governance till now and it will take some time for us to realize the fruits. If the intentions are good, results will obviously follow. In any case, I feel any government can only be a facilitator. Once the right environment is created, it is for the entreprenuerial Indian to seize the opportunity. After a long pause, your clarity and precision of throught is refreshingly assuring. Thanks

Honarblle Shri Nilesh Bhai. you have done a good job not only by commenting openly but also by doing a good home work and analysis before commenting. I am sure that India will be a heaven for foreign investors too.

I am very small to comment on you, but this time I cant resist to appreciate. A big fan of yours

Nilesh you have done a good job not only by commenting openly but also by doing a good home work and analysis before commenting. I am sure that India will be a heaven for foreign investors too.

There are always opinions like Jim has one, Nilesh Shah has another and they need not match rather no 2 opinions even from same person match since the context, time, circumstances differ. With this I agree on points raised by Jim and unfortunately I have to agree with Congress on Land Bill. We may loose our Independence soon worst that British Raj. They may have taken away Gold but BJP is taking away LAND and handing over to Industrialist. Looks like Mafia Raj coming too soon. Its certainly not reforms. Do not fool the country.

My heartiest congratulations to Nilesh Shah & wealth forum. I was cont watching media highlighting negative news, interviews of so called opinion makers of the markets. Bullet point reply is really gives more clarity. Though markets may slide further but then i have more clarity. Thanks to Nilesh Shah and Wealth forum for highlighting such articles.

Well done Mr.Shah, this type of counter defend will surely make India an attractive investment destination for the outer world. Your views and perceptions for Indian economy are very much inspiring.

Very insightful article. The answers by Mr. Nilesh Shah are straight to the point. I have attended a meet few months back at Surat, where Mr. Nilesh Shah made a presentation & I also got opportunity to ask few questions to him, then & now also he responded well. Warren Buffet has rightly said, “You cant produce a baby in one month by getting nine women pregnant.” Results take time & India is a place where states are larger than some of the countries in the world.

Hats of to Mr. Nilesh for such a bold reply to so called arrogant gurus. We have so much potential that these gurus are jealous and it seems that just to stay in lime light they make such statements. I request that the letter should be printed in all newspapers. Again kudos to Nelesh Shah. We are proud of him.

Very good explanation, This will show our stand towards our country. Great.

Great! Nimesh Sir. Thanks a lot.

Great Job Mr. Nilesh. You have put the facts in perspective.

Mr. Shah, you are absolutely right. It reminds me your “Back to Basic“ presentation in Kolkata 5 years ago.

I agree with Nileshs views BUT am more and more skeptical about Mr.Modi. Let us consider "Swachh Bharat" , Modi could have done a much better job by Enforcing/Enacting TOUGH laws to ensure Cleanliness. Swachh Bharat has become a joke. The decisions on Coal mines and Especially on Spectrum sale were NOT up to the mark. Modi had a very good chance of making Good on Spectrum sale. The land bill has become a mess and Of all things Congress is Gaining Ground on this issue.

Congratulations. I am very proud of you that you have boldly put forward your arguments and opinions with facts and figures. More than the right or wrong about the issues raised I feel taking on any foreign personality is a sign of courage and conviction hardly demonstrated by any indian expert.

Superbly Explained in a simple way....... Thanx for sharing the details.....

Kudos, very well said. I think it has become fashion to criticize India. Not only foreigners but even our own todays generation.

Nice. Thank you for the explanation.

WELL EXPLAINED ABOUT India`s GROWTH STORY SIR.

Absolutely in agreement with Prabal da. Very well said Sir.

Jim Rogers may have made billions. But one should understand that he is no God.He has views may be contrarian to what actually he is doing. Just listen and take your own decision. As money is yours not any so called expert....

CONGRATULATIONS! Very well explained.

Very True Nileshbhai, I came across one article of the Jim Rohn dated 24th Sep 2013, where he has said that move out of India and invest into the North Korea. http://blogs.marketwatch.com/thetell/2013/09/24/jim-rogers-forget-india-try-myanmar-or-north-korea-for-next-em-bonanza/ I just did a small comparison between North Korea’s Kospi and NIFTY. Kospi Nifty 24th sep 13 2001 5892 Today 2104 8100 (Even after huge correction) Return Abs. 5% 37.47%

Every party had made promises in garnering votes - most of them has turned into damp squib. Very recently I had a chance to interact with some foreigners who were on a business trip. They were very categorical about the cooperation they have received from the government official which was not there 2 years ago. Well, to many Indian ache din meant getting up in the morning to find a wad of currency beside the pillow. Mr Modi called for a swatch Bharat we started littering more. He has good intentions but we are enough in our small ways to jeopardise them. He needs time and lots of cooperation from the citizens. Its not a single persons job. Did we ever notice how much bak bak we do? Easy to point fingers at others,